Soccer ID camps: which ones are worth the money
How to tell a recruiting camp from a fundraiser: what an invite really means, which camps to pay for, and the e-mail to send a coach before you register.
An ID camp is the one recruiting expense that feels like progress the moment you pay for it. Sometimes it is. A weekend on a campus in front of the staff that already wants a closer look at you can move your recruiting forward. A camp you joined because an e-mail said you were "identified" usually moves money from your account to the program's budget, and little else.
The difference is rarely the camp. It's what you did before you registered. Here is how to sort them.
What an ID camp is, and what the invite means
A college ID camp is a camp run by a school's coaching staff, usually on campus, where players train and play in front of that staff. Under NCAA rules a Division I school's camp must be open to any and all entrants, limited only by number, age, grade level or gender. Ability isn't on that list. Anyone who pays and fits the age group can come, so getting in tells you nothing about your level.
Camps also earn money for the program, which is why the invites go out so widely. Coaches are allowed to invite specific players as long as the camp is advertised and open to everyone, and they can send camp information to younger players they can't otherwise answer. An invitation is not an evaluation. As recruiting consultant Renee Lopez told SoccerWire, being invited does not mean you're being recruited. A good test is whether that coach has ever seen you play live. Another: if every player on your club team got the same e-mail, it's marketing.
The rules that shape the weekend
A few rules change what you should expect once you get there.
- No special treatment on price. Prospects can't get free or reduced admission. A coach who is keen on you still can't waive the fee, so a discount is no signal either way.
- No private sessions. Staff can't work only with specific prospects. Coaches have to work with everyone, so being in a big group is normal and not a bad sign.
- Age limits what a coach can say. Division I soccer coaches generally can't call or e-mail recruits back until June 15 after the sophomore year. What they can say at a camp before then is limited, so a quiet coach at 15 doesn't mean a coach who isn't interested. School compliance offices word the camp rules differently, so treat younger-player conversations as restricted.
- The dates are limited too. Camps can't run during a sport's dead period. Rules move, so check the current calendar and the school's own compliance page before you plan around a date.
Division II has its own dates, and Division III is less restrictive. See what each level really means for how they differ.
Why roster limits raise the stakes
Division I schools that opted in to the House settlement now carry a roster limit of 28 in both men's and women's soccer. Fewer spots at those programs means a smaller class to fill and less room for a player nobody planned on. A coach at one of those schools is less likely to find you for the first time at a camp, which makes the work you do before you arrive matter more.
Which camps are worth paying for
Rank a camp higher for each of these you can answer yes to.
- The school is on your real list. You would go there if the coach said yes tomorrow, and it fits your grades, budget and level. Build that list first with how to build your target list.
- The staff already knows your name. A coach has replied to you, watched your film or seen you play, and you're going to give them a second look.
- It's a single-school camp. Those run by the school's own staff give you far better access to the people who would recruit you. Multi-school camps can look like better value, but listed coaches don't always attend, and those who do may be the most junior person on staff. Ask who is actually coming.
- The numbers are reasonable. SoccerWire's guidance is that more than about 50 players starts to be too many for a coach to see you properly. Ask for the cap, and how many are registered per position. Feedback often goes to only a handful of players, so plan to earn your own conversation.
- You'd be glad you went even if no one calls. Seeing the campus and talking with current players is worth something on its own, as long as you can afford the trip.
Skip it if the e-mail didn't come from the school, if the sender can't say who will attend, or if you're registering mainly because a teammate is. Check the sender's domain, which should almost always end in .edu, and be cautious with any pitch for a pile of schools at one price.
Add up the whole weekend first
Before you register, write down the full cost: fee, gas or flights, hotel, food and any time off work. Then compare it with what the same money buys elsewhere. For many families the honest order is a sensible club schedule first, then good film, then one or two camps at schools that have shown interest. Most players are better off with a few well-chosen camps than a full summer of them. Stay at your own recruiting pace, not the one in your inbox.
The e-mail to send before you pay
This takes ten minutes and is often the best recruiting step in the whole process, because it tells the coach you're coming and tests whether they care. Find the right person in the staff listing, then send it two or three weeks ahead. The structure comes from how to e-mail a college coach.
Subject: [Your Name], [grad year] [position], [Club Name], considering your [month] ID camp
Coach [Last Name],
I'm a [grad year] [position] with [Club Name] in [city], with a [GPA] GPA. I'm interested in [School] because [one specific thing about the program or major].
I'm thinking about attending your [month] ID camp. Could you tell me which staff will be evaluating, how many players are expected at my position, and whether the camp would be a good use of my time for the [grad year] class?
Here are two minutes of recent film: [link]. My next games are [dates and event].
Thank you, [Your Name] | [phone] | [parent e-mail]
A D1 coach may only be able to answer about the camp itself if you're young, which is fine, since that's what you're asking. A specific reply is a good sign. A form letter or nothing at all is an answer too. Save your money for a school that writes back. Short, watchable film helps, and film that gets watched covers what to include.
If you go
Introduce yourself to the staff at check-in, then play the way your film says you play. After you get home, send a short thank-you within a few days that names one thing you worked on with the staff, and keep the conversation going using after you hit send.
If you don't have a list of who to write to, the men's soccer and women's soccer pages break staffs down by level and conference. Camp or no camp, the program that recruits you will be one you kept in touch with.
Now you need the addresses
Build your list by level and state, or try 25 real contacts free first.